ACL Injury Prevention Training for Young Athletes
Steve Daisey MPT, CSCS
ACL injury is devastating to a young athlete,
virtually always requiring surgery, and at least
4 to 6 months of rehabilitation before returning
to a competitive level. Nearly 80% of the time,
injury occurs without contact from another player
(1). In other words, at a high speed, the muscular
system failed to protect the knee joint adequately,
excessive stress was transferred to the ACL,
and it simply snapped.
Females are at an even greater risk than
males, injuring their ACLs at six times the
rate of males (2). There are numerous theories
as to why this occurs including hormone estrogen
level (3), anatomical differences related to
pelvic structure (4) and the smaller size of
the female ACL coupled with a narrower notch
where it attaches on the femur (5).
Recently, research has shifted focus to the
movement patterns and training techniques of
the male and female athletes. From that research,
some startling discoveries have been made.
In a landmark study in 1996, female athletes
were found to have a marked imbalance of the
strength and power between their hamstrings
and quadriceps as compared to males (6). Because
of this imbalance, forces within the knee when
decelerating from a jump or sprint were much
higher in those athletes with less active hamstrings
(6). Studies have shown that the hamstrings
play a pivotal role in stabilizing the knee
and protecting the ACL when the knee is bending
while decelerating (6-8).
What is most exciting is that these studies,
along with others, have found that training
to correct this imbalance appeats to result
in a lower incidence of ACL injury (9,10)
We have taken
this research a few practical steps further.
We recognize that in normal, efficient sports
movement mechanics, the hip joint should
take the majority of the stress of deceleration.
In other words, athletes who frequently injure
their knees, generally over-use their knees
and under-use their hips.
If you watch a mature, seasoned, well-trained
athlete move, you will see them move through
their hips quickly and efficiently. This means
that the athlete dominates with his or her hamstrings
and gluteals (which cross the hip) moreso than
the quadriceps (which for the most part does
not cross the hip). This goes beyond strength,
and has more to do with what part of the body
the brain tells to stress first and stress most.
A young athlete at risk will often over-flex
the knees during movement. This can be seen
by the knees translating far in front of the
feet when decelerating, landing and squatting.
I have included 3 exercises that are designed
to teach the hamstrings and gluteals to be more
dominant, thereby creating movement patterns
in the athlete which will allow forces to be
decelerated at the hip and less at the knee.
This is accomplished by emphasizing the hamstrings
and gluteals.
While these are very basic exercises and
represent only a fraction of a thorough ACL
injury prevention program, they provide an excellent
beginning foundation.
The Squat
This
is one of the most important movements in sports.
If an athlete cannot perform this correctly,
he or she will be unable to use the hips efficiently,
placing entirely too much stress on the knees.
Squat down to the floor as shown. Have someone
watch to make sure your back is straight, you
are bending at the hips, and that your knees
do not go in front of your toes. Keep your head
over your feet.
Do 20 correct repetitions of this each afternoon
and each night, for a total of 40 each day.
You should feel this primarily in your hamstring
(back of the leg) and gluteal (buttock) region,
but not get overly fatigued there.
Stop if you feel this in the knees at all
or if all the fatigue is felt entirely in the
quadriceps muscle (front thigh). Have someone
else look at the picture and watch you at the
same time to critique your form.
Lateral Lunges
The lateral lunge forces the athlete to decelerate
movement through one hip at a time, placing
greater emphasis on the gluteals and hamstrings.
It also trains the young athlete to move correctly
in the lateral direction, where many injuries
occur.
Step to one side and squat toward the floor.
Drop your hip down and back. Let your
trailing leg relax and lag behind as shown.
Keep the back straight and your knees behind
your toes. Get down toward the floor by
dropping and bending your hip. Hold for one
second. You should feel this mostly in the hamstrings
and gluteals. Stop if you feel anything in the
knee joint itself.
Lateral Bounding
The next step is to take the lateral lunge
and turn it into a ballistic training exercise.
Lateral bounds train the hamstrings and gluteals
to decelerate the body at real-time speed, making
it a very functional ACL prevention exercise.
And because the ankles are involved in slowing
the momentum of the lateral movement, this becomes
an excellent ankle sprain prevention exercise
as well.
Lateral bounds are performed by hopping from
one foot to the other in a quick motion, with
very little ground-contact time. Imagine you
are bouncing from one trampoline to another.
The same form applies - knees should not
be in front of the toes when landing. Keep
the back straight and bend at the hips. Landing
should be soft and quiet with minimal ground-contact
time (see movie below).
Try doing two sets of 20 to 30 seconds with
a one-minute rest in between. As with the previous
two exercises, it is important that you feel
this in the hips, hamstrings and/or gluteals
and NOT in the knee or too much in the quadriceps.
As most young athletes are
in-season this time of year, it is important
not to over-do these exercises. While you
can do the free-standing squats each day
in order to practice your form, try the
others twice each week. They can be done
as part of a warm-up or a cool-down to practices.
References:
1. Noyes FR, et al: The symptomatic anterior
cruciate-deficient knee. Part 1: The long-term
functional disability in athletically active
individuals. J Bone Joint Surg 1983; 65A: 154-62.
2. Lindenfeld TN, et al: Incidence of injury
in indoor soccer. Am J Sports Med 1994; 22:
364-71.
3. Wojtys EM, et al: Association between the
menstrual cycle and anterior cruciate ligament
injuries in femal athletes. Am J Sports Med
1998; 26: 614-9.
4. Haycock CE, Gilette JV: Susceptibility of
women athletes to injury: Myth vs. reality JAMA
1976; 236: 163-5.
5. Shelbourne KD, et al: The relationship between
intercondylar notch width of the femur and the
incidence of anterior cruciate ligament tears.
A prospective study. Am J Sports Med 1998; 26:
402-8.
6. Hewett TE, et al: Plometric training in female
athletes: Decreased impact forces and increased
hamstring torques. Am J Sports Med 1996; 24:
765-76.
7. Baratta R, et al: Muscular coactivation:
The role of the antagonist musculature in maintaining
knee stability. Am J Sports Med 1998; 16:113-22.
8. More RC, et al: Hamstrings - an anterior
cruciate ligament protagonist: An in-vitro study.
Am J Sports Med 1993; 21: 231-7.
9. Hewitt TE, et al: Neuromuscular training
and knee injury in female athletes: A prospective
study. Am J Sports Med 1999; 27: 699-705.
10. Caraffa A, et al: Prevention of anterior
cruciate ligament injuries in soccer: A prospective
controlled study of proprioceptive training.
Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 1996; 4(1):
19-21.
|